Assembly-Line Justice: A Review of Operation Streamline

Assembly-Line Justice: A Review of Operation Streamline

Between 2003 and 2008, the misdemeanor immigration caseloads of magistrate judges along the U.S.-Mexico border increased by nearly 250 percent, from 15,633 cases to 53,697. Those caseloads continue to rise. And nationwide, federal prosecutions of immigration crimes nearly doubled in 2008 over the previous year.

These striking numbers are the result not of a flood of immigrants entering the United States, but of a set of zero tolerance immigration enforcement programs along the border. The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) introduced the first of these programs, Operation Streamline, in Del Rio, Texas, in 2005, and has implemented similar programs in five more border sectors since then. Though zero tolerance programs take slightly different forms in the various jurisdictions where they exist, they share the same mandate: the criminal prosecution of all migrants caught attempting to enter the United States in designated border areas. And though they are known by different names, the programs are generally referred to in the aggregate as “Operation Streamline.”

Operation Streamline has been lauded by its designers but criticized by many others, including judges, prosecutors, and border enforcement officials. This paper contextualizes Streamline among other immigration enforcement programs and explores some of the constitutional and policy issues that have made the program so contentious.


More in this Issue

What Does Richard Posner Know About How Judges Think?

Richard Posner may be America’s most celebrated living judge, and although he does not sit on our highest court, his career marks an unmatched fusion of judicial leadership and prolific scholarship. Given such renown and experience, Posner’s recent book How Judges Think cannot escape high expectations. Indeed, Posner cites his credentials in offering to “part[] […]

The Filipino Veterans Equity Movement: A Case Study in Reparations Theory

In February 2009, the United States enacted a law that provided $198 million in one-time direct individual payments and official service recognition to Filipino veterans who fought for the United States in the Pacific theater of World War II.1 Under the payment program, Filipino veterans with U.S. citizenship will receive $15,000, while non-U.S. citizen Filipino […]

Finding a Common Yardstick: Implementing a National Student Assessment and School Accountability Plan through State-Federal Collaboration

This paper outlines a cooperative governance scheme between the states and the federal government that will be used to develop a national student assessment program for public K-12 education. The proposed structure is based upon theories of democratic experimentalism and policy diffusion. The proposal is aimed at addressing the current problems in the No Child […]

Supplementing the DSHEA: Congress Must Invest the FDA with Greater Regulatory Authority over Nutraceutical Manufacturers by Amending the Dietary Supplement Health and Education Act

This paper addresses the serious deficiencies in the Dietary Supplement Health and Education Act, or “DSHEA.” In it, I argue that the DSHEA (a federal statute passed by Congress in 1994, superseding the Food Drug and Cosmetics Act as the applicable law governing the sale of nutraceutical products) gives impermissible latitude to manufacturers of dietary […]

Compensating for Executive Compensation: The Case for Gatekeeper Incentive Pay

Financial markets are in crisis again and quite certainly on their way to an added layer of regulation. Only a few years ago, at the start of the twenty-first century, a massive wave of corporate fraud revealed the failure of corporate gatekeepers. The Sarbanes-Oxley legislation accordingly targeted gatekeepers, primarily auditors, with strict regulation and enhanced […]

Post-American Securities Regulation

International securities regulation has arrived at the forefront of the country’s debate on financial market reform. The global economic crisis has exposed the enormous systemic risk that can arise where securities are sold across borders. Meanwhile, the Bernie Madoff and Allen Stanford frauds have illustrated the international reach of swindlers and conmen. Consequently, policymakers have […]