Beyond Privacy, beyond Rights – Toward a Systems Theory of Information Governance

Beyond Privacy, beyond Rights – Toward a Systems Theory of Information Governance


For decades, we have refined concepts of information privacy, as well as intellectual property, that are largely based on individual rights. Such an approach is undeniably appealing. It does not necessitate a large enforcement bureaucracy, ostensibly enhances human freedom and self-determination, and ensures efficient information allocation through robust markets. As this article explains, a rights-based approach may even lead us to a convergent and coherent concept of information governance on either side of the Atlantic. Such a convergent conception would, however, not be able to extend to both the United States and Europe. For that it may behoove us to take a serious look at the bidirectional information rights structures emerging in Europe. The problem with such rights based approaches is that they have largely failed in practice. In contrast, information privacy protection works when it rests on a rich and deep network of information governance intermediaries. This article concludes by suggesting that studying the system of information privacy and copyright in particular, and of information governance in general, and examining what mechanisms of governance are employed by the various intermediaries may yield a richer, more accurate, and more effective strategy for information governance than the current rights-based approach.

PDF

More in this Issue

Mainstreaming Privacy Torts

In 1890, Samuel Warren and Louis Brandeis proposed a privacy tort and seventy years later, William Prosser conceived it as four wrongs. In both eras, privacy invasions primarily caused psychic and reputational wounds of a particular sort. Courts insisted upon significant proof due to those injuries’ alleged ethereal nature. Digital networks alter this calculus by […]

Protecting Privacy in Health Research: The Limits of Individual Choice

In his groundbreaking 1967 study, Privacy and Freedom, Alan Westin defined privacy as “•the claim of individuals, groups, or institutions to determine for themselves when, how, and to what extent information about them is communicated to others. Many data protection laws enacted since then have followed suit, relying on choice””often together with notice necessary to […]

Our Unsettled Ninth Amendment: An Essay on Unenumerated Rights and the Impossibility of Textualism

The Ninth Amendment””our resident anarchic and sarcastic “constitutional jester”””mocks the effort of scholars and judges alike to tame and normalize constitutional law.”¨The Amendment stubbornly resists control. It stands as a paradoxical, textual monument to the impossibility of textualism, an entrenched, settled instantiation of the inevitability of unsettlement. If it did not exist, constitutional skeptics would […]

Sex Offender Civil Commitment: The Treatment Paradox

Twenty-one states and the federal government have civil commitment schemes that provide for the further confinement of sex offenders after they have completed their prison sentences. These schemes survive constitutional scrutiny on the grounds that they are not a second prison sentence, but rather serve the non-criminal ends of protecting society and helping treat violent […]

Cracks in the Foundation of Federal Law: Ameliorating the Ongoing Mortgage Foreclosure Crisis through Broader Predatory Lending Relief and Deterrence

The ongoing U.S. mortgage foreclosure crisis worsened significantly in 2008 and the first half of 2009. At the end of September 2009, a record 14.4 percent of mortgage borrowers were either in foreclosure or delinquent on their mortgages. The Congressional Budget Office (CBO) estimated that 2.2 million homeowners with subprime and Alt-A mortgages, the categories […]

Reunifying Privacy Law

In the years since Samuel Warren and Louis Brandeis proposed a unified theory of invasion of privacy tort liability, American information privacy law became increasingly fragmented and decreasingly coherent. William Prosser’s 1960 article, Privacy, which heavily influenced the Restatement of Torts, endorsed and hastened this trend toward fragmentation, which spread from tort law to the […]

Privacy – An Endless Debate

Prosser analyzed privacy against the background of American experiences. Consequently, his views were shaped by the American legislative and judicial context. But none of the developments Prosser described is a singularly American phenomenon. Prosser’s reference to Warren and Brandeis’s 1890 article in the Harvard Law Review3 could just as easily have been expanded with references […]

Prosser’s Privacy and the German Right of Personality: Are Four Privacy Torts Better than One Unitary Concept

At the fiftieth anniversary of Prosser”˜s Privacy, this Article takes a comparative approach in assessing his accomplishments. Germany”˜s legal system offers a fitting point of comparison because of its well-developed privacy law as well as its rich media landscape with similar kinds of invasions of privacy. Moreover, the United States and Germany share a Western […]

Prosser’s Privacy Law: A Mixed Legacy

This Article examines the complex ways in which William Prosser shaped the development of the American law of tort privacy. Although Prosser certainly gave tort privacy an order and legitimacy that it had previously lacked, he also stunted its development in ways that limited its ability to adapt to the problems of the Information Age. […]

Privacy Torts: Unreliable Remedies for LGBT Plaintiffs

Lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender Americans have defended their interests in dignity, equality, autonomy, and intimate relationships in the courts by appeal to the right to privacy. In the constitutional arena they have experienced noteworthy success, winning rights to same-sex intimacy and, in some states, marriage. Several authors have argued that the privacy tort is […]