Learning from the Recent Interpretation of INA Section 245(a): Factors to Consider When Interpreting Immigration Law

Learning from the Recent Interpretation of INA Section 245(a): Factors to Consider When Interpreting Immigration Law


In 1994, Congress passed the Violence Against Women Act (VAWA 1994). VAWA 1994 established the self-petitioning process, which permits undocumented battered victims to adjust their immigration status to Legal Permanent Residents (“LPRs”) in the United States without the aid or knowledge of the abusive spouse. In VAWA 2000, Congress added certain abused immigrants to those eligible for adjustment of status, exempting this class from having to have been inspected, admitted, or paroled into the United States as a prerequisite for adjustment of status. Despite Congress’ attempt to assist immigrant victims of domestic violence, however, U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (CIS) still refuses to give full effect to the provisions in VAWA 1994 and the VAWA 2000 amendments.

This comment argues that CIS’s refusal to grant adjustment of status to approved VAWA self-petitioners is clearly wrong for several reasons. First, CIS is blatantly disregarding Congress’ intent by failing to implement the immigration provisions of VAWA 1994 and VAWA 2000. Not only that, but CIS is also circumventing the statutory scheme of VAWA by misconstruing the language and application of several provisions in the INA. In addition, CIS’s policy on this matter produces odd legal consequences for most battered victims, since they will never be able to become LPRs in the United States despite having an approved VAWA application.

PDF

More in this Issue

Critical Inquiry: A Tool for Protecting the Dissident Professor’s Academic Freedom

This comment concerns the Sixth Amendment Confrontation Clause and seeks to justify why courts consistently find an autopsy report not subject to the right to confrontation under the new test created by the Supreme Court in Crawford v. Washington. The current test turns on a statement’s classification as “testimonial”; testimonial statements require confrontation, but non- […]

The Myth of International Delegation

There is a growing and misinformed sense in some quarters that the United States and other countries have engaged (and continue to engage) in delegations to international institution that involve a significant threat to domestic sovereignty. Concerns about such delegations come from academics (John Yoo: “Novel forms of international cooperation increasingly call for the transfer […]

An Analysis of Current Whistleblower Laws: Defending a More Flexible Approach to Reporting Requirements

This Comment analyzes the arguments both for and against strict report recipient requirements. This analysis reveals that neither an external nor an internal report recipient requirement provides sufficient protection to whistleblowing employees, who face a very real threat of retaliation.9 Studies indicate that whistleblowers choose their report recipient based on a wide variety of practical […]

Keeping Imports Safe: A Proposal for Discriminatory Regulation of International Trade

The benefits of overseas outsourcing have come at a cost. Americans enjoy unprecedented levels of safety and security in the domestically-produced goods they use, food and drugs they ingest, and services they employ. Yet as U.S. firms increase the efficiency of their production, become more competitive globally, and offer better price-quality combinations to their customers […]

Virginity Testing and South Africa’s HIV/AIDS Crisis: Beyond Rights Universalism and Cultural Relativism Toward Health Capabilities

In this Article, I explore the tension between the politics of culture and the rights of women and girls to equality, privacy, and sexual autonomy in the context of epidemic disease. Specifically, this Article examines the political debate surrounding the resurgence of virginity testing, its widespread popular support in certain communities, and the South African […]

Mourning Miranda

The article presents new field research about police interrogation tactics and training and discusses that research in light of recent social science literature and judicial decisions. Professor Weisselberg argues that the safeguards of Miranda v. Arizona have become ineffective””not because police are deliberately disobeying Miranda, but because officers have learned how to take advantage of […]