The Messy History of the Federal Eminent Domain Power: A Response to William Baude

The Messy History of the Federal Eminent Domain Power: A Response to William Baude

 

Christian R. Burset “¢Â 19 Dec 2013

In this response to William Baude’s article, Rethinking the Federal Eminent Domain Power, Christian Burset challenges Baude’s claim that antebellum legislators, commentators, and judges uniformly refused to acknowledge a federal eminent domain power. Examining historical sources and case law, Burset highlights how changing political attitudes influenced historic beliefs about the ability of the federal government to condemn land within state boundaries.

Recommended Citation: The Messy History of the Federal Eminent Domain Power:A Response to William Baude, 4 Calif. Law Rev. Circuit 187, https://www.californialawreview.org/the-messy-history-of-the-federal-eminent-domain-power-a-response-to-william-baude/

More From California Law Review Online

Regulating Your Face

No one likes being told what to do. It’s the reason that philanthropists prefer to contribute to the charitable causes of their choosing, rather than paying more in taxes. It’s the reason that courts have equated enforcing a contract with imposing involuntary servitude. It’s the reason for viewing government as a “necessary evil,” rather than […]

Business Interruption Coverage in the Age of Covid-19

The coronavirus pandemic has surfaced many new and interesting legal issues. Among them: What legal recourse is available to a business that lost significant profits after a governmental order forced it to close? In March 2020, for example, the Bay Area enacted a shelter in place mandate and ordered all non-essential businesses[1] to either close […]

The Aftermath of California’s Proposition 22

Uber, Lyft, DoorDash, and other gig companies who authored and advertised Proposition 22 spent a record $200 million on the ballot initiative to persuade Californians to vote it into law. In the weeks leading up to the 2020 general election, Uber and Lyft bombarded its riders and drivers with endless messaging through its apps and […]

The Biden Doctrine?: The February 25 Airstrike in Syria, Article 51, and the Future of International Law in the Biden Administration

The February 25 Airstrike in Syria In a June 2016 interview, then-Vice President Joe Biden cast doubt on the utility of interventionist foreign policy. Citing the shortcomings of the 2011 NATO-led military intervention in Libya, Biden stated that he was “strongly” against the intervention. In reference to the ouster of Libyan leader Muammar Qadhafi, Biden […]