On July 14, 2026, the Supreme Court appeared before Congress for the first time in over six years. Representing the Court, Justices Elena Kagan and Amy Coney Barrett fielded questions from House and Senate representatives during an appropriations hearing. Congress convened the hearing after the Supreme Court requested a last-minute, $14 million budget increase for security improvements, including funds to hire 100 to 150 additional court officers. The request was unusual—both in its untimely nature and in the rare glimpse behind the judicial curtain. Yet for all the Justices’ transparency towards Supreme Court security, solutions for the hundreds of lower federal courthouses remained opaque. As the head of their own branch of government, the Justices need to speak for all of Article III.
The hearing began with a sobering statistic: an expected 38% increase in serious threats against the Supreme Court—a rise Senator Susan Collins attributed in part to dangerous rhetoric from public officials “on both sides of the aisle.” Justice Barrett acknowledged the “great need” for improved security, both at the Supreme Court and at lower federal courts across the country.
For Justice Barrett, it was personal. She recounted how the increased threats have required her children to “think about and see things that children should not have to see.” For example, she testified, “I didn’t expect that performing this service was going to put me in the position of explaining to my children what a bulletproof vest was and why I had to wear one.” And she isn’t alone. Just four years ago, a suspect was arrested near Justice Brett Kavanaugh’s home with plans to break in and kill him. Violent attacks near federal courthouses are becoming more common, and this once-distant fear has become Article III’s newest job hazard.
The Justices testified that part of the effort to improve security includes staffing the Court with 24/7 security personnel. These positions will be filled by the Supreme Court Police Department, a law enforcement organization managed entirely by the Court itself, rather than the United States Marshals Service that guards lower federal courthouses. Justice Kagan staked out a long-term goal of 477 total officers under the Court’s control. But the Justices explained their struggle in reaching that goal with their current budget allotment, compounded by the officers’ demanding workload and long hours.
Just as hiring officers for the Supreme Court police has been difficult, appointing quality Article III judges has become a challenge of its own. Judge John Coughenour of the Western District of Washington said in an interview that if he “were in [his] 30s or 40s with young children at home and thinking about going on the federal bench,” he would consider whether he was exposing his family to violence. Justice Barrett acknowledged that increased threats to judges risk deterring qualified candidates from joining the bench, as they might “feel like the security of them or their family will suffer.”
One cause for judicial hesitance in joining the bench is the increase in rhetoric attacking judicial integrity. Another is the lower courts’ necessary role in earlier stages of litigation. Pivotal rulings for and against the Trump administration place judges in the spotlight for bitter constituents to direct their anger. CNN’s website hosts an interactive page listing quotes from named federal judges who criticized President Trump; to a political extremist, this is an easy list of people “disloyal to our Constitution.“ To make matters worse, judges now face calls for impeachment when their rulings do not conform to the President’s desired outcome, deterring qualified candidates.
Judges’ concerns about their safety and credibility are far from hypothetical. Judge Coughenour had armed police show up to his home after a false caller claimed that he had murdered his wife. The next day, another call: this time a bomb threat. And earlier this year, Judge J. Michelle Childs of the District of Columbia Circuit received a mysterious pizza delivery at her door. Other judges have received similar deliveries, often under the pseudonym Daniel Anderl—the name of Judge Esther Salas’s son, tragically killed in 2020 by a politically radicalized attorney. Justice Barrett called these deliveries what they are: intimidation and harassment.
But as the Court advocated for its own security improvements, discussion of lower-court improvements was curiously sparse. Judges with experiences similar to Justice Barrett were not present to tell their own stories at hearing, despite the problem reaching all levels of the federal judiciary. Part of this stems from the fact that the lower courts and Supreme Court are operated by two distinct bureaucratic structures. The General Services Administration, an executive agency under Article II charged with the upkeep of thousands of federal buildings and beleaguered by staff cuts, is responsible for the lower federal courts’ security. This stands in stark contrast to the Supreme Court, which governs itself independently from Article II.
This unusual setup puts the Supreme Court in a precarious position: advocating for its own improved security, knowing it operates separately from the hundreds of lower federal courts facing the same problem. The lower courts have sought to regain independence over their finances, security, and buildings from the executive branch since 1989. Recent exposure to outside threats only adds fuel to the flame. Yet the Justices offered no testimony to suggest their own financial independence would spread down the judiciary.
The current setup is flawed. The executive branch controls the budget, buildings, and the protection of over 850 federal lower-court judges. And while no political actor has yet weaponized that authority, one could—with dire consequences. Namely, an administration could reassign a judge’s protective detail after an unfavorable ruling. The problem is compounded when the lower courts cannot advocate for their independence as effectively as the Supreme Court. For example, the lower courts do not have the luxury of outsourcing their security needs to contractors.
This structural gap was on full display at the July hearing. None of the planned changes at the Supreme Court would have any bearing on the nation’s other courts. The Representatives almost seemed to recognize this better than the Justices. Many of the questions at the hearing asked how Congress could better ensure the safety of lower courts. Little of substance was given in response.
Of course, the Supreme Court and lower federal courts operate within two different bureaucracies. But as the leaders of the Article III branch, the Justices should take a more active role in pushing for increased protections for all federal courts. Chief Justice John Roberts, in particular, as the head of Article III and its tens of thousands of employees, is best positioned to resolve this tension. The Chief Justice presides over the Judicial Conference, which plays a critical role in proposing and formulating the judiciary’s annual budget request. But Chief Justice John Roberts was not the one testifying. Few of Justice Kagan and Justice Barrett’s remarks would have a significant impact on their lower federal judge counterparts.
In the modern political landscape, more is needed to protect judges. And the Court must play a more active role in protection. Whether that be by advocating for an Article II decoupling or for budget increases, something must be done for the federal judiciary. The Supreme Court has shown it knows how to ask for what it needs. Now, it must use its influence to protect all of Article III.
Copyright © 2026 Braxdon Cannon* and Cole Troutner**
* J.D. Candidate, University of California, Berkeley, School of Law, Class of 2027.
** J.D. Candidate, University of California, Berkeley, School of Law, Class of 2027.