The web edition of the California Law Review.

CLR Online

Online Article, November 2026, Kristen Holmquist California Law Review Online Article, November 2026, Kristen Holmquist California Law Review

The People the Puzzle Forgot

Even in a good year, constitutional law can be a little jarring for some students. It might be the first place they experience a disconnect between the ideals that led them to law school and the legal world’s messier realities. Many of us, regardless of our politics, want to read the Constitution as a moral document. If we find the right way to interpret it, it will show us the way toward a just society. So, when students learn that even after Brown, schools remained segregated; that even while Roe remained good law, many women were denied access to abortions; or that after Dobbs, the number of abortions in the United States increased—that can be destabilizing. Or they discover that Constitutional law is full of compromises and balancing and tests that come seemingly out of nowhere. A student once asked me, “Isn’t the major questions doctrine made up?” When I answered, “Well, sure. But so is strict scrutiny, in a sense,” the class had to grapple with the fact that the Constitution isn’t self-executing. Justices must do the messy work of implementing its not-always-easy-to-understand provisions. And they get it both “right” and “wrong” in ways that can be frustrating. So even in a good year, the class can be hard. But this year was not a good year.

Read More