Articles, notes, and symposia pieces published in CLR’s print volumes.

Print Edition

Note, Volume 108, December 2020, Shawn Trabanino California Law Review Note, Volume 108, December 2020, Shawn Trabanino California Law Review

Health, Law, And Ethnicity: The Disability Administrative Law Judge And Health Disparities For Disadvantaged Populations

Social determinants play into who gets to die prematurely while others get to have healthy productive lives—these are loosely called health disparities. Health disparities are typically understood socially, economically, and politically, but rarely analyzed within the legal system. The Social Security Administration (SSA)—the federal program for providing Americans with disabilities benefits and…

Read More
Note, Volume 108, December 2020, Kelly Seranko California Law Review Note, Volume 108, December 2020, Kelly Seranko California Law Review

What Happened to Full Faith and Credit?

In Franchise Tax Board v. Hyatt (Hyatt III), the Supreme Court overruled forty-year-old precedent that allowed a citizen to sue a state in another state’s courts. The Court’s 5–4 decision creates another barrier for plaintiffs who seek to hold states accountable. Hyatt III expands the doctrine of sovereign immunity to provide states additional protection against…

Read More
Note, Volume 108, December 2020, Abigail Burnam California Law Review Note, Volume 108, December 2020, Abigail Burnam California Law Review

Abortion Sanctuary Cities: A Local Response to The Criminalization of Self-Managed Abortion

You live in Mississippi, work an hourly, minimum wage job, have no savings, and have young children. You are also seven weeks pregnant and want to have an abortion. Technically, you can go to an abortion clinic. But even though you have Medicaid, it won’t cover any of the procedure’s costs because Mississippi generally follows…

Read More
Symposium, Essay, Volume 108, December 2020, Daphna Renan California Law Review Symposium, Essay, Volume 108, December 2020, Daphna Renan California Law Review

“Institutional Settlement” in a Provisional Constitutional Order

I want to press a bit on the question of what the unwritten aspects of our constitutional structure establish. Rather than a fixed legal order constructed by conventions, I want to suggest that this unwrittenness points to the provisionality of the constitutional order itself—that is, to its essentially unsettled character. This perspective raises three problems…

Read More

Against Constitution by Convention

The Constitution emerged from a convention—a convention of the states. State popular conventions, by ratifying it, made it law. Though it was meant to “form a more perfect union,” no one could have supposed the Philadelphia Convention’s proposal was anything close to perfect. Indeed, the Constitution’s terms refute any blithe confidence in its flawlessness. Article…

Read More
Symposium, Essay, Volume 108, December 2020, Katherine Shaw California Law Review Symposium, Essay, Volume 108, December 2020, Katherine Shaw California Law Review

Conventions in the Trenches

In this Essay, I identify several shifts in focus that might further illuminate the intersection of constitutional conventions and judicial review: first, attending to the role of internal executive-branch conventions, which are distinct in important ways from settlements between the political branches that are Issacharoff and Morrison’s primary focus; second, widening the lens to include…

Read More

Constitution by Convention

We are told that we live in the era of textualism. Inspired by the commanding presence of Justice Antonin Scalia, many accounts of American constitutional law focus on, and stress the preeminence of, the written word. On this view, the contractual sense of the constitution as a defined pact means that the intentionality of the original…

Read More
Article, Volume 108, December 2020, Erin Murphy, Jun H. Tong California Law Review Article, Volume 108, December 2020, Erin Murphy, Jun H. Tong California Law Review

The Racial Composition of Forensic DNA Databases

Forensic DNA databases have received an inordinate amount of academic and judicial attention. From their inception, numerous scholars, advocates, and judges have wrestled with the proper reach of DNA collection, retention, and search policies. Central to these debates are concerns about racial equity in forensic genetic practices. Yet when such questions arise, critics typically just…

Read More
Article, Volume 108, December 2020, Amna A. Akbar California Law Review Article, Volume 108, December 2020, Amna A. Akbar California Law Review

An Abolitionist Horizon for (Police) Reform

Since the Ferguson and Baltimore uprisings, legal scholarship has undergone a profound reckoning with police violence. The emerging structural account of police violence recognizes that it is routine, legal, takes many shapes, and targets people based on their race, class, and gender. But legal scholarship remains fixated on investing in the police to repair and…

Read More
Article, Volume 108, December 2020, Pooja R. Dadhania California Law Review Article, Volume 108, December 2020, Pooja R. Dadhania California Law Review

Paper Terrorists: Independence Movements and the Terrorism Bar

This Article explores the application of the terrorism bar in immigration law to noncitizens who have participated in an independence movement. It proposes a uniform standard that immigration adjudicators can use to determine whether a foreign entity is a state in order to promote accurate applications of the terrorism bar. The terrorism bar in the…

Read More

Does <em>Revlon</em> Matter? An Empirical and Theoretical Study

We empirically examine whether and how the doctrine of enhanced judicial scrutiny that emerged from Revlon and its progeny actually affects M&A transactions. Combining hand-coding and machine-learning techniques, we assemble data from the proxy statements of publicly announced mergers between 2003 and 2017 into a dataset of 1,913 unique transactions. Of these, 1,167 transactions were…

Read More
Note, Volume 108, October 2020, Nina Lincoff California Law Review Note, Volume 108, October 2020, Nina Lincoff California Law Review

Looking to Hybrid Species for the Future of Coral Reefs

Although corals can hybridize and adapt to the threat of climate change, the existing legal framework in the United States is insufficient to ensure their protection. This regulatory gap leaves hybrid corals exposed to local and regional stressors. But legal protections, like the corals themselves, can adapt and evolve. If we value coral reefs, we should modify the…

Read More
Note, Volume 108, October 2020, Ping Liu California Law Review Note, Volume 108, October 2020, Ping Liu California Law Review

Making the Grade: Rethinking the U.S. Food Retail Inspection and Rating Regulatory System

The FDA’s oversight of food retail has not kept pace with modern legislation’s move toward standardized guidelines across the food industry. Instead, the FDA’s feeble attempt at a command-and-control model has crumbled into a system that is de facto deregulated and lacks uniformity…

Read More
Article, Volume 108, October 2020, Robert A. Schapiro California Law Review Article, Volume 108, October 2020, Robert A. Schapiro California Law Review

States of Inequality: Fiscal Federalism, Unequal States, and Unequal People

Two potential solutions that have been proposed for addressing the fiscal disparity among states are (1) following the lead of other federal nations and adopting a system of interstate fiscal equalization or (2) ending federalism and fully nationalizing key programs. As I will discuss, neither of these polar solutions is feasible or desirable. Instead, drawing on…

Read More
Article, Volume 108, October 2020, Dara E. Purvis, Melissa Blanco California Law Review Article, Volume 108, October 2020, Dara E. Purvis, Melissa Blanco California Law Review

Police Sexual Violence: Police Brutality, #MeToo, and Masculinities

The epidemic of PSV [police sexual violence], both in scale and in concept, is startlingly underanalyzed. Sexual assaults committed by police against members of the public operate at the intersection of two vital national conversations about police brutality and sexual violence and harassment…

Read More
Article, Volume 108, October 2020, Asad Rahim California Law Review Article, Volume 108, October 2020, Asad Rahim California Law Review

Diversity to Deradicalize

In articulating a new explanation of Powell’s motives in Bakke, this Article not only calls into question the prevailing understanding that Powell was motivated by his commitment to racial justice, it also complicates a more critical view of the diversity rationale that locates the Court’s endorsement of “the educational benefits of diversity” in a recognition that exposure to racial minorities confers…

Read More
Article, Volume 108, October 2020, Jessica Lynn Wherry California Law Review Article, Volume 108, October 2020, Jessica Lynn Wherry California Law Review

Kicked Out, Kicked Again: The Discharge Review Boards’ Illiberal Application of Liberal Consideration for Veterans with Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder

Rather than continue this pattern of punishing veterans for having mental health conditions—commander kicks them out and the discharge review board kicks them again—veterans deserve the opportunity for true relief in recognition of their service and the mental health condition they developed due to that service…

Read More
Note, Volume 108, August 2020, Anne Weis California Law Review Note, Volume 108, August 2020, Anne Weis California Law Review

Fleeing for Their Lives: Domestic Violence Asylum

This Note argues that it is a mistake to classify domestic violence as a primarily “private” crime given its widespread and gendered nature. Further, in some cases, the infliction of domestic violence is ignored—if not condoned—by state actors, casting doubt upon Attorney General Jeff Sessions’s claim in Matter of A-B-that such violence does not involve…

Read More
Article, Volume 108, August 2020, Nadia N. Sawicki California Law Review Article, Volume 108, August 2020, Nadia N. Sawicki California Law Review

The Conscience Defense to Malpractice

This Article presents the first empirical study of state conscience laws that establish explicit procedural protections for medical providers who refuse to participate in providing reproductive health services, including abortion, sterilization, contraception, and emergency contraception. Scholarship and public debate about law’s role in protecting health care providers’ conscience rights…

Read More